Redress still being decided “by the offender”, says academic two years after apology

Two years on from the government’s apology to survivors of abuse in care, University of Auckland Associate Professor Stephen Winter says the redress system is still built on a “massive conflict of interest”. Winter, who was part of the survivor-led redress design group, told Radio Waatea’s Dale Husband the government didn’t adopt the Royal Commission’s…


Two years on from the government’s apology to survivors of abuse in care, University of Auckland Associate Professor Stephen Winter says the redress system is still built on a “massive conflict of interest”.
Winter, who was part of the survivor-led redress design group, told Radio Waatea’s Dale Husband the government didn’t adopt the Royal Commission’s recommendation for an independent redress body.
“When the government looked at the implications of that broad approach, I think there was a little bit of concerns about the purse strings, and they wanted to ensure that they kept control of the process so that they had control over the money that was being spent.”
He said payments have improved but are still well behind schemes overseas.
“So that went up from about 19,000 New Zealand dollars to 30,000 New Zealand dollars… However, if we look internationally, 30,000 average is very low. Both the Australian and the Scottish ones… they’re over $100,000 each on average.”
“So in that respect, New Zealand’s four to five times less than two comparative schemes that are running right now.”
Husband said the issue hits Māori hard.
“It’s such a Māori issue. So many of our young men ended up in care, as you’re well aware, and then their trajectory for their lives was, to be honest, quite shocking and disappointing.”
Winter said the most important step is moving to an independent system.
“We’ve just got this massive conflict of interest right now. The government is deciding what redress it’s going to pay, how much it’s going to pay, what kinds of evidence is going to be necessary to justify those redress claimants, how that evidence is going to be assessed. That’s all being done by the offender, right? The conflict of interest is just so glaring.”
He said that independence has to be financial.
“That means a redress body that has a capital grant, a chunk of money and a significant chunk of money that’ll provide it with the ongoing financial independence so it doesn’t have to come back cap in hand to the government asking for more… If I was going to circle one thing, that’s the really big thing. And if we can’t get that, everything else is a little bit sort of trying to fix a fundamentally broken system.”

Author