22 JOBS GONE: MĀORI PROVIDER WARNS VIOLENCE CUTS WILL PUSH MORE WORK ONTO THE FRONTLINE

A Porirua kaupapa Māori health provider is warning that major staffing cuts to the Government unit responsible for coordinating the response to family and sexual violence risk pushing more work onto frontline organisations without providing the money to do it. The Centre for Family Violence and Sexual Violence Prevention is being restructured, with 35 existing…


A Porirua kaupapa Māori health provider is warning that major staffing cuts to the Government unit responsible for coordinating the response to family and sexual violence risk pushing more work onto frontline organisations without providing the money to do it.

The Centre for Family Violence and Sexual Violence Prevention is being restructured, with 35 existing roles disestablished and 13 new positions established — a net reduction of 22 roles. The Ministry of Justice says the new structure will sharpen the Centre’s focus while retaining specialist capability, strengthening Māori capability and improving coordination and data functions.

But Carole Koha, Pou Kaihautū of Te Waka Whaiora in Porirua, says reducing the national team to 13 positions raises serious questions about how a national strategy to eliminate family and sexual violence can be effectively led and coordinated.

Her concern is straightforward — when government capacity disappears, the violence doesn’t.

The work instead lands with organisations already supporting the whānau affected.

Frontline providers already dealing with the consequences

Te Waka Whaiora provides kaupapa Māori, whānau-centred services across mental health, addiction, housing, crisis support and reintegration.

The organisation says family and sexual violence is frequently part of the experience of tāngata whaiora coming through its doors, even though violence prevention may not be the specific service they were originally referred for.

Te Waka Whaiora’s wider service model includes primary mental health and addiction, community addiction support, crisis respite, sustaining tenancies, forensic mental health and housing and recovery services.

Koha says that creates a major gap between what government contracts measure and what frontline organisations actually see.

A person may arrive seeking help with addiction or mental distress, but the underlying trauma can include years of violence or sexual abuse.

Treating one issue without confronting the other risks treating symptoms while leaving their cause unresolved.

Who is counting the people nobody counts?

Te Waka Whaiora is also raising concerns about the quality of the information government uses to understand the scale of family and sexual violence.

Koha says only a limited number of organisations are specifically contracted to report family and sexual violence data, while many other providers encounter the consequences of violence through mental health, addiction, housing and other services.

That creates the possibility that official reporting captures only part of what is happening within communities.

The Government’s own national approach recognises that eliminating family and sexual violence requires coordination across agencies, tangata whenua, specialist organisations and communities.

Te Aorerekura, the national strategy, includes building skilled and culturally competent workforces as a central part of eliminating family and sexual violence.

The question raised by Te Waka Whaiora is whether the organisations already encountering violence-related trauma should be formally resourced to identify, respond to and report that work.

79 providers already involved in changing services

The wider family violence system is itself undergoing substantial change.

The Ministry of Social Development says 79 providers around Aotearoa are currently involved in Te Huringa ō Te Ao, designing, delivering and testing new approaches to family violence services.

Those providers include Māori, Pacific and community organisations operating from Northland through to the South Island.

That illustrates the scale of the network required to respond to family violence.

But Te Waka Whaiora argues accountability needs to be matched with funding.

If government expects providers to identify violence, collect information, respond appropriately and contribute to a national strategy, organisations need the workforce and resources required to carry out those responsibilities.

Māori providers see problems that don’t fit neatly into contracts

The issue is particularly important for kaupapa Māori organisations because whānau do not necessarily arrive with one isolated problem.

Housing insecurity can sit alongside addiction.

Mental distress can sit alongside violence.

Financial hardship can sit alongside trauma.

Contact with the justice system can sit alongside all of them.

A contracting system that separates those experiences into different government funding streams can look very different from the reality confronting a whānau.

Previous Māori expert advice to the health system has emphasised greater investment in people and communities, prevention and Māori-led solutions to family and sexual violence.

The He Kaupapa Waka report argued that communities need the ability to design, lead and deliver responses appropriate to their own needs and aspirations.

For Te Waka Whaiora, that means recognising the violence-related work already being carried out outside specifically contracted family violence services.

Government says Māori capability will be strengthened

The Ministry of Justice presents a different view of the restructure.

Secretary for Justice Andrew Kibblewhite says consultation resulted in changes to the original proposal, including retaining specialist capability and relationships and strengthening Māori capability.

The final structure also provides for increased governance and communications support and stronger coordination and data capability.

Eleven of the 35 positions being disestablished were already vacant, while 13 new roles will be created.

The Government’s test will therefore be whether a considerably smaller Centre can deliver those functions effectively.

For providers, the test will be what happens on the ground.

Violence doesn’t disappear when a government position does

Family and sexual violence cannot be addressed by one agency alone.

The effects can eventually appear in hospitals, mental health services, addiction treatment, schools, housing providers, Police, courts, prisons and community organisations.

Health New Zealand itself recognises family violence can include physical, emotional, psychological, financial and sexual abuse, with health services forming part of the wider system responding to that harm.

That interconnectedness sits at the centre of Te Waka Whaiora’s warning.

Cutting government positions does not reduce the number of whānau dealing with trauma.

It does not reduce the number of people arriving at mental health and addiction services.

And it does not remove the responsibility somebody eventually has to carry.

For Koha, the question is therefore not simply whether the Centre can operate with 13 positions.

It is who picks up the work that no longer happens there — and whether those frontline organisations will finally be funded for the work they are already doing.

#FamilyViolence #SexualViolence #TeWakaWhaiora #CaroleKoha #Porirua #KaupapaMāori #WhānauMāori #MāoriHealth #HauoraMāori #MentalHealth #Addiction #Trauma #FamilyHarm #TeAorerekura #TeHuringaOTeAo #ViolencePrevention #CommunityProviders #SocialServices #GovernmentCuts #PublicServiceCuts #MāoriProviders #WhānauOra #TeAoMāori #Aotearoa #WaateaNews #RadioWaatea

Author