No-show, is not a no-vote: The Meaning of Abstention in Tāmaki Makaurau

In a by-election defined by what didn’t happen, Oriini Kaipara and Te Pāti Māori secured 6,031 votes to Labour’s Peeni Henare on 3,093,  a majority of 2,938, according to Electoral Commission results. Just 9,377 ballots were cast from around 44,000 enrolled, a turnout of 21.3 percent. On the surface, such a low turnout suggests apathy.…


In a by-election defined by what didn’t happen, Oriini Kaipara and Te Pāti Māori secured 6,031 votes to Labour’s Peeni Henare on 3,093,  a majority of 2,938, according to Electoral Commission results. Just 9,377 ballots were cast from around 44,000 enrolled, a turnout of 21.3 percent.

On the surface, such a low turnout suggests apathy. A closer look, however, points to a different possibility: abstention as strategy.

Te Horopaki – The Context

In 2023, Takutai Tash Kemp – Te Pāti Māori captured Tāmaki Makaurau as part of a sweep that saw TPM win six of the seven Māori electorates. Her untimely passing triggered the 2025 by-election. Re-standing for Labour, senior MP Peeni Henare, whose return to Parliament was already assured by his high 14th position – on Labour’s list. Oriini Kaipara, former broadcaster, carried the TPM banner to defend the seat.

From the first returns, Kaipara led decisively. Yet the deeper story lies in why so many Labour-aligned voters did not show up.

Te Ariā Kāore i Te Pōti – The No-Show Hypothesis

Henare’s supporters knew his return to Parliament as a list MP was secure. But a by-election victory for him would have done more than confirm his seat, it would have added an extra Labour MP to caucus, while cutting Te Pāti Māori back to five. Choosing not to vote was therefore less about indifference and more about calculation. By sitting out, many Labour-aligned whānau effectively allowed Te Pāti Māori to retain Tāmaki Makaurau, preserving six kaupapa Māori voices in the House. Abstention became a strategy: a no-show was not a no-vote, but a way of shaping the overall balance of representation.

Ngā Tatauranga mō te Kore Pōti – The Numbers Behind the Abstention

In 2023, Peeni Henare won 10,026 electorate votes in Tāmaki Makaurau. In 2025, his tally collapsed to 3,093 – a drop of 6,933. But turnout is the key.

As a share of enrolled voters: Henare fell from 22.8% of the roll in 2023 to just 7.0% in 2025, a 15.8-point fall. As a share of those who actually voted: his support slipped only modestly, from about 39% in 2023 to 33% in 2025. Breaking it down, about 92% of Henare’s drop came from lower turnout, not defections to Te Pāti Māori. His actual share of active voters fell only six points.

The picture for Te Pāti Māori is the mirror opposite. Takutai Tash Kemp won 11,584 votes in 2023; Oriini Kaipara secured 6,031 in 2025. On raw numbers that looks like a fall, but relative to turnout the story is different.

As a share of enrolled voters: TPM dropped from 26.3% in 2023 to 13.7% in 2025. As a share of those who actually voted: TPM grew from about 45% to over 64% – a near 20-point increase.

In short: Labour’s voters stayed home, TPM’s turned out. This abstention explains the swing: not mass defection, but differential mobilisation.

Ngā Āhuatanga Anō – Other Factors

By-elections everywhere attract lower participation. Port Waikato 2023 contest, drew just 36 percent turnout; Ikaroa-Rāwhiti in 2013 reached 33 percent. At 21 percent, Tāmaki Makaurau sits at the very bottom of the range, shaped by mid-term fatigue and the absence of a party vote alongside the electorate contest. But combined with Henare’s safe list position, abstention takes on a strategic hue.

Mēnā ka tū te Pāti Kākāriki – What If the Greens Enter?

If the Green Party were to contest a Māori electorate like Tāmaki Makaurau, the equation could change. A Green candidate might siphon progressive votes from Labour while also splitting kaupapa-aligned support with TPM, lowering the threshold needed to win. In a low-turnout environment, that could prove decisive.

Ngā Pānga mō te tau 2026 – Implications for 2026

Labour’s challenge is stark. If supporters continue to reason that their MPs will return via the list, abstention could become the norm in Māori electorates. That hands TPM a built-in advantage: its smaller but highly motivated base is enough to capture seats.

To counter this, Labour must sharpen its kaupapa Māori commitments: return of co-governance and He Puapua, entrenchment of Te Tiriti in Parliament’s constitution, a return of Te Aka Whaiora. It must also rebuild trust on the ground through marae hui, rangatahi-led organising, and stronger urban Māori campaigning.

For Te Pāti Māori, the lesson is to consolidate this model, ensuring that strategic abstention by Labour voters continues to work in their favour, while mobilising their own core to carry the seats.

The Tāmaki Makaurau by-election result is not proof of apathy. It is evidence of Māori voters recalibrating their power under MMP. In 2025, silence became a strategy – one that returned Te pāti Māori via Oriini Kaipara with a decisive mandate, while keeping Peeni Henare in Parliament as Labour’s seasoned list MP.

Author